Govt, opposition reject claims of favoritism in CJ appointment

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif (right) and PTI Chairman Gohar Khan. — AFP/ Online/File
Defence Minister Khawaja Asif (proper) and PTI Chairman Gohar Khan. — AFP/ On-line/File

ISLAMABAD: The main opposition celebration and the ruling celebration have refuted the notion that they’ve a favorite decide among the many prime three Supreme Court docket justices in line for being chosen because the chief justice.

This was said by the opposition and authorities leaders on Monday within the Geo Information programme — Capital Discuss.

With the passage of the twenty sixth Constitutional Modification, which requires the highest judicial place to be stuffed three days previous to the incumbent’s retirement, the coalition authorities has begun the method of choosing a brand new prime court docket decide. The incumbent Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Qazi Faez Isa is scheduled to retire on October 25.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif stated it will be incorrect to say that the federal government had one favorite among the many three senior most Supreme Court docket judges.

“The impression that Justice Yahya Afridi is a authorities candidate for the put up of CJP is incorrect,” he stated.

The committee shaped to elect the CJ, he stated, would determine who could be the subsequent chief justice from Justice Mansoor Ali Shah, Justice Yahya and Justice Munib Akhtar.

To a question, the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief stated it couldn’t be dominated out that Justice Mansoor could be the subsequent CJ since he was among the many three prime judges.

“That is doable that anybody of Justice Mansoor, Justice Yahya and Justice Munib will get appointed,” he stated.

Speaking in the identical programme, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) Chairman Gohar Ali Khan stated the impression was incorrect that Justice Mansoor was PTI’s decide.

“This notion ought to finish that now we have some favorite decide. Now we have by no means differentiated amongst judges. We simply say that determine the instances as per the regulation and structure,” he stated.

“Because the Structure had been amended, although we thought of it unconstitutional, we might give names for the committee tasked to pick out the CJ, he stated to a question.

In the meantime, talking in ‘Aaj Shahzeb Khanzada Kay Sath’, PML-N chief Rana Sanaullah stated each celebration would have proportionate illustration within the committee as per their energy within the parliament and the CJ could be chosen with two-third majority, not easy majority.

The concept of appointment of CJ from three most senior judges was of the judiciary, not politicians, he stated.

“If a senior puisne recuses himself [for CJ’s post] then the fourth most senior decide could be included within the prime three [for election],” he added.

Answering a query, Sanaullah stated Justice Mansoor was an especially good and credible decide however the components of senior most decide’s appointment because the chief justice had inflicted profound harm to the judiciary and the nation’s judicial system.

“Those that held this seat earlier have carried out such issues which had been so pitiable,” he maintained.

New CJP to be elected right this moment

In a notification issued on late Monday, the Nationwide Meeting Secretariat stated {that a} 12-member Particular Parliamentary Committee has been constituted for the appointment of subsequent CJP.

The 12-member committee consists of eight lawmakers from treasury and 4 from opposition benches:

  • MNA Khawaja Asif (PML-N)
  • MNA Ahsan Iqbal (PML-N)
  • MNA Shaista Pervaiz (PML-N)
  • MNA Raja Pervaiz Ashraf (PPP)
  • MNA Syed Naveed Qamar (PPP)
  • MNA Rana Ansar (MQM-P)
  • MNA Barrister Gohar Ali Khan (PTI)
  • MNA Sahibzada Hamid Raza (SIC)
  • Senator Ali Zafar (PTI)
  • Senator Farooq H Naek (PPP)
  • Senator Azam Nazeer Tarar (PML-N)
  • Senator Kamran Murtaza (JUI-F)

The particular committee will maintain an in-camera sitting on the Parliament Home at 4pm on Tuesday to finalise the identify of the subsequent chief justice among the many three senior-most judges of the apex court docket with two-thirds majority.

Over the committee’s suggestion, the prime minister will ship the nomination to the president for closing approval.

If any of the three senior-most judges declines the place, the subsequent senior decide will likely be thought of for the highest slot. Presently, Justice Mansoor is probably the most senior decide, adopted by Justice Munib, and Justice Yahya.

Underneath the newly enacted regulation, the CJP’s time period has been mounted at three years except they attain the retirement age of 65, resigns sooner or is faraway from workplace following adjustments to Article 179.

Furthermore, if a prime jurist has not reached 65 years age, he would nonetheless stand retired after completion of his three-year tenure.

Moreover, the choice of the chief justice will not be primarily based solely on seniority, and as a substitute, the selection will likely be made among the many three most senior judges of the Supreme Court docket.

Then again, hours after structure of the parliamentary committee, the PTI introduced to boycott right this moment’s assembly of the Particular Parliamentary Committee, constituted to nominate the subsequent Chief Justice of Pakistan, refusing to affix the method of appointing the subsequent prime decide.

Leave a Comment